An Englishwoman at Home and Abroad.

Sunday, 23 January 2011

Is Everything Quite What It Seems?


Flights of fancy are second nature to me. Ordinary life can, rather too often in my view, be just that so I love nothing better than to daydream of yet to be visited foreign lands, to surf the virtual reality of the Blogosphere, or to lose myself in the latest book of a favourite author.

It is, perhaps, no surprise, therefore, that trompe-l'oeil has always held a fascination for me. I never cease to be amazed that, with paint alone, the eye can be deceived so completely. A technical tour-de-force, which can render flat surfaces three-dimensional, can produce space where none exists and can even bring alive whole scenes of people and places when they are but figments of the imagination.

Invented in antiquity, established by the Romans, named by the French, developed during the Renaissance and progressively perfected ever since, trompe-l'oeil has a deliberate intention to trick the eye, to fool to the point of confusion and to blur the boundaries of fantasy and reality. Such visual trickery can be remarkable, even breathtaking, when carried out well.

Occasionally, and most particularly on a Sunday, I like to lunch in the restaurant of the Tate Gallery. Not only does one eat well, but one may also escape into the imaginary world of 'Epicurania', an extensive and impressive trompe-l'oeil mural by Rex Whistler which, dating from 1927, covers the walls of the dining room. Collaborating with the novelist Edith Olivier, Whistler depicts the story of seven people on an 'Expedition in Search of Rare Meats'. On bicycles, carts and horses, the travellers pass through strange and wonderful lands, encountering unicorns, truffle dogs and giant gluttons en route. The story ends with a joyful homecoming, the diet of dry biscuits having been replaced with all manner of exotic foods gathered along the way.

At Plas Newydd, on the Island of Anglesey, Whistler was commissioned by the Marquess of Anglesey in the period between the wars to paint a mural for the dining room. This magnificent optical illusion must count as his greatest work. Highly realistic, meticulous with its attention to detail, witty yet serious, this is a glorious tribute to the art of trompe-l'oeil and to a great British artist killed tragically young whilst on active service in Normandy in 1944.

And so I ponder, should my Budapest entrance hall be transformed in the manner of Francesco Borromini's C17 arcaded gallery in the Palazzo Spada in Rome? Or, should my somewhat dull wardrobe doors be restyled as Jackie Kennedy's dressing room in the 1970s? Or, indeed, should my garden pavilions be painted with the most prized collection of potted orchids, alive and in bloom for all time? Such is the stuff of which dreams are made!

P.S. Today's picture, depicting a self portrait of the artist Rex Whistler, shows a small corner of the mural in the dining room of Plas Newydd.

P.P.S. Thank you to so many readers who left such kind and generous comments for me during my extended Christmas break.

145 comments:

Victoria said...

I completely agree. There is something about trompe-l'oeil that appeals to the child in us, I think. I love the blurring of reality and illusion, and I think that's why the Whistler works so well; there are several points at which things could stop or start being real. It's fabulous - thank you so much for showing it to us.

Cyndy said...

Dear Edith, I love the idea of Jackie O's dressing room on a wardrobe in Budapest!Welcome back from your break, and do let us know if a bit of trompe l'oiel makes it into your abode!

rohrerbot said...

I feel the same way you do Edith. I love getting lost in though and dreaming about exotic places and strange new worlds. Reading is a lot of fun but then again so is the gardening.......
If you had to choose between the 3 projects, I'd say paint the pavillions!! Then do the entrance hall.:) Enjoy your weekend.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Victoria, Thank you for your comment. I am so pleased that you agree about the Whistler mural. Such bravura, I feel, in its size and scope.....quite perfect for whisking one away from reality!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Cyndy, Thank you so much for your comment. It was, in fact, my London wardrobe that I had in mind for the JK treatment. Her trompe-l'oeil images were memories from her childhood which I thought to be such an interesting idea.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Rohrerbot, Thank you for your comment. A fellow daydreamer...how splendid! I really feel that the Budapest hall may be my first choice as it has been a work in the planning for several years now. I just need to find the right artist.....

Reggie Darling said...

Interesting, I have been fulminating a Rex Whistler post myself. I, like you, find the dining room at the Tate divine, and try and take a meal there whenever I visit London and am lucky enough to find myself at the Tate. One really doesn't care what one eats under such circumstances, for drinking in the loveliness of the walls is nourishment alone.

Terra said...

I am intrigued by this style of art too, and some cities in the US are having building exteriors enhanced in this manner. It seems you could step into the wall and the world therein. How tragic the young artist died in World War II.

Edith Hope said...

Dearest R, Thank you for your comment and Happy New Year! I am so pleased that you too enjoy the mural at the Tate. How intriguing to think of you dining there too, but I am certain that I should not dine there for the mural alone. It is indeed fortunate that the food is good too!

There is so much to say about RW and the 'Bright Young Things' that I am certain a further posting from you could well be in order. Such a pity that with such talent he lived such a short life.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Terra, Thank you for your comment. What fun the trompe-l'oeil effects on the buildings must be. I am certain that they will enhance the everyday street experiences of passers-by!!

Alistair said...

Dear Edith, so good to see you back and as inspirational as ever.Trompe-l'oeil, sorry this means nothing to me, however I can still get lost in your beautiful world. I too daydream, in fact as a child my mother would always say I was constantly in a dwam, unfortunately this is not a complimentary Scottish term used when referring to ones offspring.

Masha said...

Dear Edith
Thank you for a well-written post on a subject not often discussed in daily life. Reading it reminded me of my long-ago visit to Sistine Chapel, where I saw a trompe l'oeil for the first time. Thank you for bringing a memory back!

Carol said...

Dear Dear Edith! You are back! Your wonderfully enlightening and inspiring posts . . . such as this one . . . have been greatly missed. I hope you have been enjoying allowing your imagination to merge within enchanting trompe l'oiels and planing wondrous three dimensional illusions of your own. I see I now have another place to hopefully meet you someday for lunch. I must confess . . . to never having seen Whistler's masterpiece, but will hopefully do so in the not to distant future. Your post is an excellent and informative read.

Madelief said...

Dear Edith,

Welcome back! I hope you had a good time over Christmas?!

Such a difficult decision to make. All the projects you mentioned sound interesting. To have a trompe-l'oeil in your hall must be very impressive, but that garden pavilion with potted orchids sounds interesting as well. I see the holiday's did you good. So many ideas....


Tea in the Tate restaurant sounds good! I always enjoy going to the restaurant in the Victoria and Albert Museum. The enormous chandeliers, the lovely atmosphere....I feel very much at easy there!

Happy new week!

Lieve groet, Madelief

Britta said...

Dear Edith Hope,
I am happy to find that the announcement of a new post by you is no trompe d'oeuil! Of course I jotted it down in my little notebook: what do do/see/visit/buy when in England again (one so often forgets in the actual situation!) - "Tate t.d.o"
Thank you!

Britta said...

Hope I did write "Trompe-l'œil", can't see it now :-)

Hocking Hills Gardener said...

I admire the talent of painters so much. I am awed by how they get three dimensional objects and people to look the way they do. I love pictures of real places and things and about life and living. I have to admit I just do not get Picasso or art where I have to convince myself that there is a meaning to it somewhere. My children's crayon drawings are better.
Now that I have angered so many people by my confession I had better stop. LOL! I hope you had a wonderful time off for Christmas and keep dreaming.

Pamela Terry and Edward said...

Oh, so happy to see you've returned ! I was concerned. I love trompe-l'oeil when it's well done, and once had the canals of Venice painting on a client's dining room walls. Magnificent.

Sarah @ Modern Country Style said...

A good trompe-l'oeil looks amazing but I've seen plenty of hideous dated-looking ones too!

Oh, Edith, I'm so glad you're back - and I hope you've thoroughly recharged. ;-)

Sarahx

Charlotte said...

The fantasy of trompe-l'oeil can be just a mood-lifter. I painted such a mural on the walls of my son's bedroom once--a jungle scene. It turned out to be too stimulating & we painted over it with a nice, reassuring green.

I didn't know about JK's wardrobe. Images from HER childhood must have been interesting!

Glad to see you back, Edith.

hostess of the humble bungalow said...

Hello Edith...
I have been curious as to your whereabouts and here you are making a grand entrance with your stylish trompe-l'oeil.

How lovely the Tate sounds, and to be able to relax and recouperate after soaking in all that beauty must feel right and proper...a chance to mull it over whilst nourishing and appeasing the appetite.

I find museum and galleries have such interesting dining spots..
The Getty near Los Angeles and The Vancouver Art Gallery are two that come to mind.

How very nice that you are back !

patientgardener said...

I love trompe l'oeil as well, such a skill. I particularly like you idea of pots of orchids around the columns in your garden and as for the Jackie Kennedy dressing room what a laugh!

The Garden Ms. S said...

Dear Edith, I first fell in love with trompe-l'oeil when I was a child and have admired it ever since. I think it would be a wonderful exercise to incorporate some into your living or gardening space. What fun!

Is the Wiz said...

Dear Edith,
What a lovely boost to read you on this January day, sharp and fresh as the scent of witch hazel. Welcome back, you breath of fresh air.

Gatsbys Gardens said...

Hi Edith,

I saw a gentleman doing a demo of this technique on television recently. It was fascinating how real the stonework looked. It is a true artistic talent.

Eileen

A Garden of Threads said...

I would be painting potted orchids everywhere. To admire during my long winter months.

Anna said...

A most Happy New Year to you Edith! I am not sure whether I could concentrate on my food if I had such glorious art work in front of my eyes at the same time. My vote goes for the everlasting orchids on your garden pavillions.

My Grama's Soul said...

After reading your interesting post....I think you should transform ALL your spots to your hearts desire!! (O:

Xo

Jo

Chris said...

Interesting post, Edith. In my view very little, nowadays, it quite what it seems. Even the camera can lie :-)

Patty said...

Glad to see you are back from holidays, I certainly missed my weekly Hope post. I have not see many trompe -l'oeil, though I suspect as you said it must be well done to truly fool the eye.

The Whimsical Gardener said...

You were missed during your absence Edith! So glad to see you back. I'm fascinated by your idea - my vote is for the Jackie O dressing room on your London wardrobe...how enchanting!

Művelt Kert said...

It's great to see you again, dear Edith! A winter garden is a perfect terrain for illusions - optical as well - here, under snow.

Gary said...

Edith,
How wonderful to come on line this evening and find a posting from yourself. Trusting that you holiday was full of high adventure and maybe just a little touch in intrigue. I for one entertained the idea that you were being entertained by a Hungarian nobleman whom was smitten by your charm but alas realizing you were far above his station in life…

And once again you have enlightened as well as entertained. Trompe-l’oeil as you pointed out can truly be a breathtaking art form and as you say “when carried out well”. – G

gardenwalkgardentalk.com said...

Glad you are back and it sounds like you are going to be quite busy. Jackie O's wardrobe sounds like pure luxury, so have a go at that one, but I do love orchids.

Robert Webber said...

Edith, welcome back to the blogosphere. You have been much missed!
Yeah, done well, trompe is fab. Introduced to it early, by a vast arc of 'landscape' behind variously truncated and ballooning, but universally spiny cacti at Kew!
The key is the 'done well' bit.
Don't have a 21st c Rex Whistler on my artisan books at the moment, but here's hoping!
And that was not a pun!
Best for 2011.
R

little augury said...

How easy it is to get lost in one of Rex Whistler's murals-with their dreamlike-scapes. Ashcombe is a great resource for Edith Olivier which led me to several of her writings. It was a simpler time and none more idyllic-it would seem than before the war. I have also been a purveyor of Rex Whistler and written about him several times-of interest might be the connections with Olivier, though I am certain you are in the know and how.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Alistair, Thank you so much for your comment. I am sad that the art of trompe-l'oeil seems to have escaped you.....until now! There is nothing better in my view for a daydreamer since all[well, perhaps not all]one's fantasies can be enacted without even leaving the house!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Masha, Thank you for your comment and, thank you too for your most generous comment on a previous posting. I do agree that trompe-l'oeil seems to be somewhat out of fashion at present but when executed well can bring such fun and fantasy to either an interior or exterior scheme. 2011 is definitely time for a comeback in my view!

Edith Hope said...

Dearest Carol, Thank you so much for your kind and generous comment. What a lovely warm welcome back you have given me. Yes, dearest Carol, lunch shared together in the Tate would be a memorable experience indeed and such fun!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Madelief, Thank you so much for your kind comment and Happy New Year. I think that of all the projects it will be the Budapest hall that will be the one to take priority. But what style...that is the big question....so many ideas!!

I have never dined in the restaurant at the V and A, but as I have yet to see the newly completed British Galleries there, I really must make a visit in the near future.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Britta, Thank you so much for your kind comment. I have taken such a long break that I was beginning to lose touch with my weblogging activities altogether, but it is lovely to make contact again with such wonderful virtual friends.

Yes, do look at the Whistler mural in the Tate on your next visit to England. It is certain to amuse you and the food is good too!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Lona, Thank you for your comment.For me, the wonder of Art is that it has so many forms and facets enabling it to speak to everyone in so many different ways. It would be a dull world indeed if we all liked the same things and it is certainly a good thing if an artwork provokes one into making comment.

Happy New Year!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Pamela, Thank you so much for your comment and your concern. I love the idea of the Venetian canals on the walls of one of your client's houses.....inspirational!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Sarah, Thank you so much for your kind comment. I could not agree more about poor trompe-l'oeil.....better to leave well alone. But, this will definitely be the year that I allow it indoors provided that I can track down an artist whom I can trust!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Charlotte, Thank you for your most amusing comment. Such a pity about the jungle scene as I really loved the sound of it! I am sure, however, that a hyperactive child is the very last thing that one would wish to create and the green sounds to be much more calming.
Images of the JK wardrobes I found to be completely inspirational...so much more satisfying than two blank wooden doors!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Hostess, Thank you so much for your kind comment. You are so right that nowadays museums and art galleries generally have such wonderful places to eat. There is something rather decadent I find in being surrounded by wonderful Art and eating delicious food. What could be better?!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Helen, Thank you so much for your comment. As I have no luck with growing Orchids, a trompe-l'oeil installation of them seems to me to be the perfect solution. For ever in bloom and for ever disease free...perfect!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Ms S, Thank you for your comment. I am so pleased that you too admire trompe-l'oeil. I do so agree that it can add a touch of fun and fantasy to a garden or an interior in a stylish way if done well.

Edith Hope said...

Dearest Isobel, Thank you so much for your warm and welcoming comment. Happy New Year and I do so hope that your work situation is stabilised. Such talent as yours deserves to be cherished!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Eileen, Thank you for your comment. I agree that the best examples of trompe-l'oeil can really deceive. I am particularly fascinated by those effects which are architectural and blend almost seamlessly into their surroundings.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Jennifer, Thank you for your comment. My thoughts entirely about the Orchids...especially as I am notoriously bad at keeping the real thing alive.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Anna, Thank you for your comment. Happy New Year to you too and Happy Birthday!!

I am pleased that you too approve of the trompe-l'oeil Orchids. What fun there would be in including all manner of rare species within my humble pavilions!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Jo, Thank you for your comment. It is indeed very tempting to do them all!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Chris, Thank you for your comment. Oh, how true that is. Increasingly it does become difficult to sort out the real from the airbrushed!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Patty, Thank you so much for your kind and generous comment. Perhaps you might be tempted to try some trompe-l'oeil out in your house or garden now?!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Cat, Thank you for your comment and your warm welcome back. I am rather an admirer of JK and her style in most things. I am warming to the idea of a makeover for my rather dreary wardrobe doors.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Eszter, Thank you for your comment. Yes, a Winter Garden is the perfect place for a touch of trompe-l'oeil......but perhaps leaving out the snow!

Edith Hope said...

Dearest G, Thank you so much for your amusing and generous comment. You are so kind but I fear that your imagination runs riot as far as anything regarding me is concerned.

I can well imagine all manner of trompe-l'oeil effects at Fox Paw Lodge as it seems to me to be such a fun and excitingly artistic environment. Happy New Year!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Donna, Thank you for your comment. Yes, the JK wardrobe doors are truly inspirational and really encouraged me to be bolder with my interior designs. Nothing will be done by me, however, a I am truly hopeless with a paintbrush.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Robert, Thank you for your comment and Happy New Year! I rather think that trompe-l'oeil is well placed for a revival as these rather gloomy times in which we live call out for a touch of fun and fantasy! I look forward to seeing some such flights of fancy in your designs for 2011!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear LA, Thank you so much for your comment. I know very little about Edith Olivier and I shall be fascinated to discover more. I certainly agree about the times between the world wars and that period of history hold much interest for me. Whistler and his involvement with the Bright Young Things is a source of great intrigue....such an immensely talented group I feel.

I read with great interest your recent posting of JK and her trompe-l'oeil dressing room. Inspirational!

jodi (bloomingwriter) said...

How very good to see you back posting, Edith! We've missed your scintillating observations on gardening and life.
Temptations, temptations! I cannot say that I've seen much trompe-l'oeil done in my corner of the world--primarily, sadly, only in books and magazines. I like the idea of a conservatory full of blooming orchids, as that would suit me rather splendidly too.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Jodi, Thank you so much for your kind and generous comment. Trailblazer that you are trompe-l'oeil should be incorporated into your glorious Nova Scotia garden or garden room without delay. All you need to track down is the artist....or perhaps you could produce your own!!

Curbstone Valley Farm said...

Dear Edith, so glad to see you back! A belated Happy New Year! I'm always fascinated by a well executed trompe-l'oeil, although I've never considered adding one to a wall here. I rather like the sounds of painting your pavilions with perpetually blooming orchids though!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Clare, Thank you so much for your comment and your warm welcome back. Perhaps a trompe-l'oeil mural could be a new introduction to Curbstone Valley in 2011?!! Perhaps if it were lifelike enough it would deter your bobcat predators?!!

elizabeth said...

So glad you have reappeared!
Do hope your festive season was festive indeed.
Ah! the Tate mural --first saw it in 1963 (aged me!) on my first visit to the Tate where my daughter later worked. It is a great delight and well worth eating lots and lots to linger looking at it!
I have never seen the Welsh mural and would love to.
Are you in Budapest or London?
6'F this morning in NY.....very nasty.

joey said...

Delighted you are back, dearest Edith. I too am a day- dreamer (pipe dreams my father called them). I love the image of prized orchids ... that would never bore me!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Elizabeth, Thank you for your comment and good wishes. I am so pleased that you too have enjoyed the Whistler mural at the Tate. Yes, I am certain that you would also like the one at Plas Newydd and the situation of the house is absolutely glorious but quite a trek from London.

I am in London at present and have spent rather longer than I wished to do in the grey drizzle over the Christmas season. I hope to spend Spring in Budapest as that is such a wonderful time of year there and the Music Festival is marvellous.

I hope that you are well and that your Moroccan adventure will be successful.

Edith Hope said...

Dearest Joey, Thank you so much for your comment and your warm welcome back. A fellow daydreamer....how marvellous. I have always wondered why they are pipe dreams.....

Cassandra said...

Welcome back, Edith! You have been missed...

How I enjoyed this posting on trompe-l'oeil and of fantasizing, myself, about various examples which could be executed at my homes: a meadow with sheep (which would be forever fluffy and require no care or expense) on the side of my farm's barn...French doors through which would be painted a forever-blue-sky beach and ocean scene on the wall of my courtyard lanai in Florida...

Ah, the possibilities are endless!!! Thank you! Cassandra ♥

Paul C said...

Trompe l'oeil - to fool the eye...I marvel at what reality and fantasy painters, decorators, architects, writers... can render. Glad to see you back.

Carolyn ♥ said...

To dream is surely bliss and you pose some wonderful daydreams. If you want my opinion... definitely go with the orchids. So nice to have you back, dear Edith, but do tell... did you have a marvelous time in some exotic place?

Mr. McGregor's Daughter said...

I like trompe-l'oeil too, but haven't seen any good examples in a long time. You've reminded me of when I was attending university in Chicago & the bus I rode to get there would go past a building with a great on on one side of it. Sadly, that building fell victim to urban renewal. I say go wild with the paint.

Jennifer@threedogsinagarden said...

Dear Edith, The long collection of comments, which proceeds my own, speaks volumes as to how very much you have been missed. I hope that you had a wonderful Christmas.
I have visited the Tate Gallery many times, but can not recall if have ever had the pleasure of eating lunch there.
While I too am inclined to flights of fancy, I have a practical side as well. I would think that your decision must be determined by the talents at your disposal. It takes a gifted artist to execute a trompe l'oeil well.
May I suggest a fourth option? Have you considered a chinoiserie? There are many beautiful hand printed chinoiserie that feature exquisite birds and flowers.

PlantPostings said...

Edith: So glad you are back! I, too, imagined you on a wild, exotic holiday trip. Your posts are always fascinating and your words thought-provoking. Welcome back! Beth

leavesnbloom said...

Dear Edith

I missed you and I'm so glad to see that you are posting again. For me you would probably guess that it would be the orchids for me any day. I've never been the to Tate but my friend goes down once and awhile when in London and she "gets lost" in there and isn't the same for a few days afterwards as she doesn't want to come back into reality.

Mark and Gaz said...

Thoroughly enjoyable post as always Edith!

I too occasionally like (and enjoy) getting lost in my thoughts thinking about exotic places to see and new projects to do. And it's amazing what your trail of thoughts can lead to!

I've always had admiration for the artist Rex Whistler so it's nice to read your little homage.

Painting the pavilions sounds nice, and the wardrobe too :)

Good to see you blogging again, was wondering before with your long abscence :)

Edith Hope said...

Dear Cassandra, Thank you so much for your kind comment. Oh how I love the idea of a sheep scene on the wall of your barn. As you say, a permanently serene pastoral view which would require no work just merry musings!! The possibilities are indeed endless and what fun it is to dream them up.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Paul, Thank you for your comment and kind wishes. Yes, I agree, the boundless limits of the human imagination are indeed marvellous!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Carolyn, Thank you for your comment. Unfortunately no exotic place for me this Christmas holiday and a mountain of obligations prevented me from even going to my beloved Budapest for more than a few days. I aim to rectify this as Spring approaches so perhaps my daydreams may be translated into reality before too long.

Edith Hope said...

Dear MMcGD, Thank you for your comment. I do think that the time is ripe for a revival of trompe-l'oeil in both public and private spaces. The only problem is ensuring its quality since poor examples can be very tacky.

Amy said...

Dear Edith,
HELLO! :) It is so nice to see that you have returned from your break. I hope you had a wonderful holiday. You were missed in the blogging world.
Also, I think you should have a Jackie Kennedy dressing room! For myself...I can imagine a Frank Lloyd Wright design inspired home. :)It is fun to dream.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Jennifer, Thank you so much for your kind comment. Chinoiserie.....ah yes! My friend M had decorated some years ago now a whole room with hand painted Chinese scenes and it looks absolutely wonderful. However, the artist virtually moved in with her as it took so long and was most certainly not cheap!! A brilliant idea Jennifer.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Beth, Thank you for your comment. Oh, if only the wild, exotic holiday had been true...the reality was much more hard work and rather sad at times so I am looking forward to the Spring to indulge my fantasies.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Rosie, Thank you so much for your kind comment. I know exactly how your friend feels after a visit to the Tate. The V and A does this to me too. So much that is so wonderful to see......a cultural overload which does take time to recover from.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Mark and Gaz, Thank you so much for your generous comment. Your own wonderful garden certainly suggests to me that you must both be highly imaginative and artistic individuals. Perhaps a little trompe-l'oeil on your new fence might be fun?!!

Mark and Gaz said...

Thank you Edith!

Not sure about trompe-l'oeil on the fences just because neither of us are good enough with painting.

But we could do minimalist, modern, and maybe a touch of abstract :)

I do like the idea of trompe-l'oeil on certain parts of the garden or home, done well it gives a touch of classic nostalgia, and very continenetal.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Amy, Thank you so much for your kind comment. JK's dressing room looked so much fun and made mine seem rather ordinary in comparison. I just do not know if I have the courage to make such a bold change.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Mark and Gaz, Welcome back. I am sure that whatever you decide the finished result will be stylish and original. I look forward to reading about what you finally decide upon.

Barbara said...

Dear Edith, welcome back in the blogosphere. How I would love to join you for lunch with a view of that fabulous-sounding mural. The journey depicted sounds almost Chaucerian. And I wonder why the artist depicted himself with a broom? Enjoyed your post, Barbara

Edith Hope said...

Dear Barbara, Thank you for your comment. Yes, I agree....Chaucerian is exactly the word to describe the mural which is of almost epic proportions. I am certain that you would find it fascinating.
I have absolutely no idea why Whistler should have chosen to depict himself with a broom.....but it is fun to imagine why!!

the gardeners cottage said...

dearest edith,

thank you this morning for my faux vacation to budapest. so happy to have you back. i hope you are well-rested and ready for a new year.

xo
janet

Plantaliscious said...

Dear Edith, welcome back to the blogoshere, you have been missed! Trompe-l'oeil done well can be magical. Plas Newydd is a case in point. I love the idea of you having works of art created on your wardrobe doors and in your entrance hall, as I am sure you would only commission high quality works. Sadly I have developed a distinct aversion to trompe-l'oeil in gardens having seen far too many really poor examples...

Edith Hope said...

Dear Janet, Thank you for your comment and kind wishes. I do so hope that a real holiday to Budapest may be a possibility one day!!
I hope that you are keeping to your resolution to have more fun in 2011!!It sounded like a splendid idea to me.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Janet, Thank you for your comment. I could not agree more. When badly done, trompe-l'oeil can look more wooden than the board on which it is painted. But, Whistler's are marvellous and do inspire me to commission an artist...several of whom appear to be talented exponents of the Art. I shall see.....

The Idiot Gardener said...

I tend to like pictures of nudey women. Generally, I don't care whether they are painted well or not; I even look at the crappy ones.

Once Mrs IG and I strolled around the art gallery in Havana. It was very dull, aside from some Rita Longa sculptures. I was all for going for a beer until we reached the top floor. I stood in amazement, pointing, and exclaimed, 'Nudey Women'. As I stepped forward a guard appeared and destroyed the day by shouting, 'Museum Closing'.

I don't much about art, but I know what I like!

Carolyn @ Carolyn's Shade Gardens said...

What a wonderful essay on an intriguing topic. I appreciate the fact that you were able to convey your thoughts with some excellent writing without the need for a multitude of photographs. Good writing is in short supply but lovely photos abound.

John Gray said...

plas newydd is just down the coast from me
lovely place
isnt there a famous paining of a violin at CHATSWORTH HOUSE?

Tess Kincaid said...

Welcome back, dear friend. I would love to lunch with you someday in the Tate. Thank you for your kind comment on my poetry today. x

Jacqueline said...

Dear Edith,
First of all, a very happy New Year to you and yours and I wish you a wonderful and magical 2011.
I adore trompe-l'oeil.....I am unhealthily fascinated by it and am in awe of anyone who can trick my eye. ....and what better way to pass a few hours than in the restaurant of the Tate. XXXX

Edith Hope said...

Dear IG, Thank you for your comment. You do surprise me....naked women...I should never have guessed in a million years!!
Can I suggest that you 'pep up' your garden shed this year with a little trompe-l'oeil? Naked women or otherwise it might offer you a diversion from the vegetables?!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Carolyn, Thank you so much for your generous comment. As I have no camera, the writing has to take centre stage. I am so pleased that you enjoyed what I wrote and hope that you will enjoy future postings.

Edith Hope said...

dear John, Thank you for your comment. How lovely to have Plas Newydd so near.
I am not sure about the violin at Chatsworth but would feel that this is most likely to be the case. I shall try to find out.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Willow [You will always be so to me}, Thank you so much for your comment. Oh what gossip we could share over lunch at the Tate, or indeed anywhere else for that matter.
Your poetry is always inspiring and you read it so beautifully.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Jacqueline, Thank you so much for your comment and kind wishes. I suspect that we should both be as one about trompe-l'oeil....at once fascinated and overwhelmed with ideas about what could be painted and how!! How easily it could all run away with one!!

fer said...

Back in my country we had some government buildings with big paintings and murals in the walls. They are quite striking and you feel immerse while walking next to them.
Welcome back!

Alice Joyce said...

Edith,
I have missed you and especially your musings, which I depend upon to help fuel & activate the 'little grey cells'.
I often wonder what it would be like to have the skill to paint a trompe-l'oeil scene. It's a technique I find fascinating.
That said, I enjoyed a wonderful meal at the Tate last May, complete with a delightful conversation shared with the couple - strangers from Australia, seated next to us. .....Perhaps I'll be seated next to you on one of my sojourns. Wouldn't that be a surprising chance encounter.
Of course I always have lunch at least once while in London at Tate Modern, quite a different setting! It's fun to identify the restaurant in movies, as it seems to often be used as a set.
Welcome back, Edith!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Fer, Thank you so much for your comment and for becoming my latest follower.
I am sure that I should find your country absolutely fascinating in so many ways. But, I cannot see me spending so much time in an aeroplane as I become agitated after an hour in the sky!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Alice, Thank you so much for your kind and generous comment.
Tate Modern is indeed wonderful and so, I feel, in an entirely different way is the Tate at St.Ives in Cornwall. Each one of the Tates really maximises its own unique qualities and that makes one's visits so very special.
I often think that we share similar views on so many things. Perhaps one day we shall exchange them face to face. What fun that would be!

Catherine@AGardenerinProgress said...

Edith you're back! I had checked your blog about a week ago wondering if I had missed something. I love trompe-l'oiel too, I only wish I was talented enough to paint like that. My brother in law is an artist and I've been thinking of asking him to paint the back of my bothy :) in some type of garden scene.
You were missed!

Sarah Laurence said...

Welcome back and happy new year! I’m fascinated by trompe-l’oeil too and murals. I once painted a mural in Vienna 1900 style for a wall in my college’s café and vowed to never do another it was so painful to do and that was when I was 19 or 20.

Sarah @ Modern Country Style said...

...and will you be posting a picture of it once you've found your trusted artist?

Pleeeeease?!

Sarahx

Edith Hope said...

Dear Catherine, Thank you so much for your kind comment. Oh yes, do have a garden scene painted on or in THE BOTHY!! That would be such fun and add would be an exciting addition to your very pretty garden.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Sarah, Thank you so much for your comment. I love the sound of your Vienna mural....but what work!! It must have looked [and probably still does look] very splendid. Are you not just a little bit tempted to try another? I know that I should if I had half as much artistic talent that you have.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Sarah, Welcome back. I must award you 11/10 for perseverance in trying to get me to include photographs in my postings!! But then, dear Sarah, where would the mystique lie?!!!

P.S. I still do not have a camera.

Martin Neill said...

Hello Edith, thank you for the fave. I will explore your blog with interest, it looks intriguing!

Martin

Edith Hope said...

Dear Martin, Thank you for your comment. I am delighted that our paths have crossed and look forward to our future dialogue.

debsgarden said...

Dear Edith, welcome back to the blogosphere! I missed you. I hope you had a wonderful Christmas and New Year holiday. I can't believe January is almost over!

I have dreamed of having a trompe-l'oeil garden scene painted above the wainscoting in my master bath. Perhaps one day I will find a young Whistler who could accomplish it. How sad that such a great talent was cut so tragically short.

charlottesplot said...

Dear Edith, thank you so much for visiting my blog, I've just had a lovely look around yours and will return when I have time to read your posts at a more leisurely pace. I used to live in London, so it is fantastic to stumble across a blog like yours, that provides a little window on the city I grew up in. I'll be back!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Deborah, Thank you for your comment and kind wishes. Oh, I do so hope that one day you will find your own Whistler and forge ahead with your bathroom project. Charleston House has some wonderful painted scenes in the bathroom, including nude figures on the side of the bath...I am very tempted!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Charlotte, Thank you for your generous comment. I am so pleased that we have found each other and look forward to our continuing dialogue.

Picture of Elegance said...

Dear Edith, I think Trompe l'oeil always convey the sense of grandeur. You can see Jackie's closet doors covered with Trompe
l'oeil in one of my recent posts.
I'm glad you're back...

Edith Hope said...

Dear PoE, Thank you for your kind comment. Yes, I agree, trompe-l'oeil does add a sense of drama and grace, lifting a room or piece of furniture out of the ordinary. I love the idea of JK's wardrobe doors being given this treatment and now shall shamelessly copy her!

RainGardener said...

Edith how good to be back and reading your post. I had seen you were gone for a while but my head was also gone (still a little maybe)and I wasn't visiting anyone. I'm trying to get it back and do what I enjoy so much, visiting everyone's blogs.
I just love looking at trompe-l'oeil. Years ago when I was painting and we had just bought this fixer upper home I had a few books on it and wanted to do a simple piece in the laundry room to practice before we painted it. I did one with lattice around the top by the ceiling with a vine weaving in an out. It would have to be simple because I certainly didn't know what I was doing but loved playing with it and giving it a try.
Such a treat to eat at the Tate Gallery and enjoy the artwork - with the added plus of good food!

Belinda @ Wild Acre said...

Hello Edith, an interesting post, one always wonders what might have been created by wonderful artists who fell on the battlefields of the 20th century. There is something very graceful about Whistler's paintings.

sandrajonas.com said...

Dear Edith,
Welcome back, you have been much missed!!
Trompe de l'oeil when well executed can indeed transport one into the realm of fantasy. I have incorporated this into tiny town gardens I have designed to very good effect. Unfortunately the artist I engaged retired. She was very talented.
I'm adding LUNCH at the Tate to my London 'to do' list.
I'm so glad you are back!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear RG, Thank you so much for your comment. How clever you are to be able to create a trompe-l'oeil effect. I am sure that it was most successful and wonder that you have not been tempted to try a more ambitious project, perhaps outdoors in the garden?

I do so hope that your health is improving. Soon the dreary winter days will be over and spring always makes one's spirits lift I find. Do take care of yourself....and perhaps plan a painting project when the weather improves!!

Edith Hope said...

Dear Belinda, Thank you for your comment. Yes, it is tragic how many talented young lives were lost in both world wars.
I am always in awe when I consider the extraordinary depth and breadth of Whistler's work which he accomplished in his very short life.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Sandra, Thank you for your kind comment. Oh, how wonderful to have been able to incorporate some trompe-l'oeil work into garden plans. I am sure that the clients loved it but, as you say, one does rely so heavily on a good artist being able to carry the whole thing off.

Yes, lunch at the Tate...an essential when you are next in London!

Christina @ Fashion's Most Wanted said...

Dear Edith, how lovely to have found your blog! I love lunch at the Tate too. And may I add a resounding yes to Jackie O's dressing room, how fabulous xx

Edith Hope said...

Dear Christina, Thank you for your comment and for becoming my latest follower. I am so pleased to know that you too frequent the Tate dining room. Yes, a copy of JK's wardrobe doors [or closet doors as no doubt she referred to them as]are being planned for Maida Vale!!
I discovered your wonderful weblog via dearest R and shall now investigate how to 'follow' you more closely!!

catmint said...

Magical fantastical images - the only limit is of the imagination. I have a friend who is an artist and she has painted a trompe d'oeil on a wall at the bottom of her garden. You have inspired me to photograph it and write a post about it. I hope you had a good break, welcome back.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Catmint, Thank you so much for your comment. I do like the sound of your friend's wall and shall look forward to reading of it in a future posting.
Thank you for your kind wishes and Happy New Year!!

Sarah @ Modern Country Style said...

How's your search for you very own trompe l'oeil coming on?

Sarahxx

Edith Hope said...

Dear Sarah, Welcome back. No luck yet but this will be the year of the trompe-l'oeil.....I am determined!!

Katy Noelle said...

Hello, dear Edith!

"trompe-l'oeil has a deliberate intention to trick the eye, to fool to the point of confusion and to blur the boundaries of fantasy and reality. Such visual trickery can be remarkable, even breathtaking, when carried out well."

It's wonderfully put! I have to say, though, that, for a moment, I thought that maybe you were presenting us with a verbal "trompe l'oeil" - the story of this mural is so pleasant and funny and the idea, very whimsical! I am so happy that there are people in this life with that much imagination and creativity. Everything would be so ordinary without them, eh?

Being the Laura Ashley junkie that I am, when we first opened the tea room, I very, very much wanted to have Sunday park scene with gardens and tea tables painted on the wall of the tea room. My sister is talented enough - she could have done it but, before she got to it, we'd put a welsh dresser there. My dream was crushed. Oh, well! I'm dreaming with you, Edith!

Love, Katy

Edith Hope said...

Dearest Katy, Thank you so much for your comment. How wonderful it would have been had your sister been prevailed upon to paint the walls of your tea room with an inspired mural. Indeed, your fame could well have spread beyond the shores of America with the tea room becoming a place of pilgrimage - and with it huge profits.

I do think to have run a tea room is such an exciting thing to have done. But then I think - all that hard work and all that baking and boiling of kettles!!

Katy Noelle said...

Oh, Edith, I'm really, really laughing. Keeping the kettle boiling can really turn into an art, at times. Also, I remember, one October morning (1:00 am, to be exact), stirring a huge pot of soup and thinking that I was stressed and dying but what a happy way to go!

I miss all of the stimulating and interesting people that I would have a chance to visit with. I miss that very, very much. I just loved offering hospitality in this way.

Thank you for your responses!

Love, Katy

Edith Hope said...

Dearest Katy, Welcome back. I am so pleased to hear that you are in good humour. I become more and more aware of the absurdity of life in all its aspects as every day passes!!

dona said...

I admit I'd never put a trompe-l'oeil in my house, however I have always been intrigued by them.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Dona, Thank you for your comment. Italy has so many wonderful examples of trompe-l'oeil and I agree that they are most intriguing.

Peter Simpson said...

Edith I stumbled across your blogsphere this evening about Rex Whistler and his murals. I have voluntered at Plas Newydd for the last ten years and have become a devotee of Rex's. There was a short item on the mural, it is actually on canvas stuck to the wall, on the BBC 1 One Show last Monday 18th and this can be seen on BBC Iplayer until Monday 25th. Hope you can catch it.

Edith Hope said...

Dear Peter, Thank you for your comment in which I was most interested. I had not realised previously that the mural at Plas Newydd is actually painted on canvas. Is this so of the one at the Tate?

How wonderful to have been a volunteer for the National Trust at Plas Newydd. It must prove to be a most interesting and, at times, odd experience.

Peter Simpson said...

Edith The Tate painting is I believe a mixture of canvas and mural.There are a number of canvases which were painted in situ over a two year period. The Plas Newydd canvas is 58 feet by 12 and a half and was woven specially in France.Painted in a Lambeth theatre studio and then carried to Anglesey by train and there stretched and stuck to the wall. It took three months to get it perfectly flat. Rex then developed the painting further and it remains unfinished as he was working on painting out some of the many boats when due to a shortage of chinese white paint and his commission in the Welsh Guards he finally left Plas Newydd in the early 40's. He was killed on his first day of action in July 1944. It is wonderful to find so many people who think so well of rex's ability. His professor at the Slade said he had met onlt three natural draghtsmen in his time and Rex was one of those.
The role of volunteer has helped my wife and I to settle into our 'new' home here on Anglesey giving us at a stroke a wide range of friends with a similar outlook and in rex has given me an interest to develop my knowledge and understanding of his wide ranging works and talent. The look of wonder on the faces of the visitors as they walk along the painting seeing it change its perspctive dramatically is reward in itself.
Peter Simpson

Edith Hope said...

Dear Peter,
Thank you so much for taking the time and trouble to write for a second time. I very much appreciate it and all the additional information which you have supplied.

I wish both you and your wife a long and happy retirement on Anglesey.